Japan Crate vs TokyoTreat: Comparison Chart
| Japan Crate | TokyoTreat | |
|---|---|---|
| Types of Sweets | Focus on contemporary Japanese snacks | Focus on contemporary Japanese snacks |
| Quantity | – | 1300g |
| Price (3-month subscription) | $45.99/month | $35.5/month |
| Shipping | Free (except some countries) | Varies from country to country, but in the U.S. it is $12.50. |
| Safety | No allergen information | Allergen and ingredient information available. |
| Reviews | Number of reviews: 12,088Average review rating：4.7 | Number of reviews：21,130Average review rating：4.8 |
| Company | Bokksu Corporation (U.S.A.) | Ichigo(Japan) |
| Official Site | Check | Check |
Japan Crate and Tokyo Treat are both boxes filled with contemporary Japanese snacks. The number of reviews and ratings indicate that both are highly rated and popular.
They are operated by different companies and charge different prices, but what are the features of each? We would like to take a closer look at what they have to offer.
Japan Crate vs TokyoTreat: A Detailed Comparison of Features
Japan Crate and Tokyo Treat are similar among Japanese snack subscription boxes in that they both focus on modern snacks. At first glance, Tokyo Treat’s prices seem more affordable, but what about the contents, shipping costs, and overall variety of snacks?
We would like to introduce in detail which one has what features. Please take a look at them for reference.
Box Design
The Japan Crate box design features a large Japan Crate logo in the middle of a brightly colored box.
One of the unique features of Japan Crate is that some months are themed around an anime or manga character. When the theme is the same, the box design will of course depict the character, and the box itself will be something you will want to keep forever.
Tokyo Treat, on the other hand, also has a different theme each month, and the design changes accordingly. This brightly colored box has a large “TOKYO TREAT” written on it, and the logo stands out. The illustration on the top side of the box is sometimes used depending on the month, but it is unobtrusive so as not to distract from the logo, and the illustration on the side of the box is mainly based on the theme of the month.
Type/content of snacks included in the box
| Japan Crate | TokyoTreat | |
|---|---|---|
| Types of Sweets | ・Candy ・Chocolate Snacks ・Potato chips ・Candy ・Drinks, etc. | ・Instant Noodles ・Drinks ・Japan-only and seasonal Kit Kat ・Chocolate Snacks ・Potato chips ・Cakes, cookies and sweet breads |
Looking at the snacks in the boxes, the Japan Crate boxes contain a variety of snacks based on each month’s theme, but there seems to be no set category of items that are always included.
Comparing past boxes, there is a good balance of chocolate snacks, candy, gummies, candy bars, and potato chips. Drinks are also included, ranging from carbonated beverages to oshiruko (sweet red-bean soup) and soup, depending on the month.
The snacks also include packages of cartoon characters and world-famous snacks such as Pocky and Kit Kat.
Tokyo Treat, on the other hand, has a certain category of snacks that are included in each month’s package. The categories are easy to understand, although the types of snacks vary within each category, such as instant ramen noodles, drinks, chocolate, potato chips, and so on.
Tokyo Treat is unique in that it is designed and packaged in Japan, so you can enjoy seasonal Kit Kat flavors that are only available in Japan. It is also rare to find sweet buns in the box.
The amount of snacks in the box
| Japan Crate | TokyoTreat | |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity | 15-17pieces | 15-20pieces(1300g) |
The number of snacks in the Japan Crate is 15-17 and the Tokyo Treat is 15-20, both of which vary from month to month. The number of snacks in the package is not much different.
Both have a lot of full-sized snacks, and from the looks of it, they seem to be well worth it. The same is true for the drinks, which are included in each package.
Prices
| Japan Crate | TokyoTreat | |
|---|---|---|
| 12 months | ＄39.99/mo | ＄32.5/mo |
| 6 months | ＄43.99/mo | ＄33.5/mo |
| 3 months | ＄45.99/mo | ＄35.5/mo |
| 1 month | ＄49.99/mo | ＄37.5/mo |
Looking at the rates, Japan Crate seems to be a little more expensive. Both offer one-time purchase, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month contracts, and the longer the contract, the more economical the one-time payment is.
However, Japan Crate basically does not charge shipping fees, while Tokyo Treat charges an additional shipping fee, so there is not much difference in the total price including shipping fees.
Shipping Method
Japan Crate’s shipping method is USPS, which takes 7-10 business days to ship from Japan. For other countries, Japan Crate is shipped by Airmail, which is affiliated with Japan Post, and takes about 1-3 weeks.
Basically, there is no shipping charge, but we recommend that you check in advance if your country is eligible for free shipping, as there are additional shipping charges for shipments to some countries.
Tokyo Treat offers several shipping methods, which vary by country. For example, if you are in the U.S., you are eligible for Express Shipping, which means that your order will be shipped within 3-5 days of receipt, and from there it will take 5-10 days to arrive. From there, it takes 5-10 days to arrive.
Shipping costs vary from country to country, but in the U.S., for example, there is an additional shipping fee of $12.50.
Safety information such as allergen information
| Japan Crate | TokyoTreat | |
|---|---|---|
| Allergen | No allergen information | Listed both on the official website and in the guide included in the box. |
| Vegetarian | No vegetarian information | Mentioned as to whether it is vegetarian or not. |
Japan Crate’s official website does not list any allergen or vegetarian information, nor does it indicate that the company is unable to provide a special assortment for allergy sufferers.
Unfortunately, the website does not recommend this service for allergy sufferers.
Tokyo Treat, on the other hand, provides information about the snacks that will be delivered the following month, including allergen information for each one and whether or not it is a vegetarian snack. The same information is also included in the booklet inside the box, so you can check it again before you eat it.
If you want to send the box as a gift to someone, the allergen and vegetarian information will be helpful to the recipient.
Number of reviews
| Japan Crate | TokyoTreat | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of reviews | 12,088 reviews | 21,130 reviews |
| Average review rating | 4.7 | 4.8 |
The reviews show that both are highly rated, but Tokyo Treat has by far the most reviews.
The Japan Crate was reviewed by people who said they liked all of the snacks and shared them with friends who also like Japan. Some people liked all of the snacks in the package, while others particularly liked the first flavor of snacks they tried.
However, one reviewer found that some of the snacks were out of date. This may have been especially true for those who live in areas where it takes a long time for delivery. However, the support team will get back to you as soon as possible.
On the other hand, Tokyo Treat received an overwhelming number of 5-star reviews, with many people saying that they tried it for the first time and found it to be very tasty, or that they would not have chosen it if they did not know about it themselves. Some said that the snacks in the package were well balanced with chocolate, gummies, and potato chips.
However, some said it took quite a few days to receive the package. Again, it depends on the country you live in, but we would like to keep in mind that it may take some time because of the shipping from Japan.
Operating Company
Japan Crate is operated by Bokksu K.K., which is headquartered in the United States. The company is headquartered in the U.S., but it also has an office in Japan and operates from two locations, packing and shipping in Japan.
Therefore, you will find authentic Japanese snacks in the boxes, and you can also get Japan-only snacks, etc. This has the advantage that authentic Japanese snacks are selected from the perspective of people living overseas.
Tokyo Treat, on the other hand, is a Japanese company called Ichigo Co. Ichigo does not outsource the packing of their snacks, but rather does it themselves, and they are very dedicated to making sure that any corrections are made as soon as possible. This is a great relief for the buyer.
Japan Crate vs Tokyo Treat｜Which is better in the end?
Japan Crate and Tokyo Treat have been examined in detail, and it is clear that they are very similar, but not the same. Both are boxes of assorted authentic modern Japanese snacks, and both are attractive when compared in price and content.
While Japan Crate has the disadvantage of not having allergen or vegetarian information, we found it to be perfect for Japanese anime lovers, with its collaboration boxes featuring anime characters.
It is also perfect for those who like to collect and decorate, as each month contains one fun item to collect. I would say that it is for those who like to enjoy themselves.
Tokyo Treat, on the other hand, provides information on the allergens and vegetarian content of each item in advance and in the booklet included in the box after purchase. This is an excellent feature, and I felt it was very safe to send as a gift to someone.
The Tokyo Treat weighs in at a solid 1300 grams, which is also a great point.
If you are a fan of Japanese culture, especially anime and manga characters, I would recommend the Japan Crate, and if you like modern Japanese culture in general, I would recommend the Tokyo Treat.
